+- International Simulation Football League (https://forums.sim-football.com)
+-- Forum: Community (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Media (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=37)
+---- Forum: Graded Articles (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=38)
+---- Thread: *The Awards Committee Review (/showthread.php?tid=17647)
*The Awards Committee Review - Modern_Duke - 01-10-2020
Here is the Original Awards Committee Post, which not a single person had any issues with.
Nailed It
DSFL Kicker of the Year - Jordan Jackson
DSFL Defensive Back of the Year - Kacey Dream
DSFL Defensive Lineman of the Year - Kyle Idlewyld
DSFL Offensive Lineman of the Year - Samuel Bakhtiari
DSFL Wide Receiver of the Year - Rayne Gordon
DSFL Runningback of the Year - Darrel Williams
DSFL Quarterback of the Year - Jay Cue
DSFL Performance of the Year - Jay Cue
DSFL Defensive Player of the Year - Kacey Dream
DSFL Most Valuable Player - Kacey Dream
NSFL Punter of the Year - Neo Donaldson (co- with Baxter Frost)
NSFL Kicker of the Year - Alex D
NSFL Defensive Back of the Year - Richard D'Attoria V
NSFL Linebacker of the Year - Lanzer Grievous
NSFL Defensive Lineman of the Year - Grayson Kuusela
NSFL Offensive Lineman of the Year - Brave Ulysses
NSFL Runningback of the Year - Ludiculo Bigby
NSFL Quarterback of the Year - Corvo Havran (co- with Franklin Armstrong)
NSFL Breakout Player of the Year - Ludiculo Bigby
NSFL Offensive Rookie of the Year - Ruff Ruff
NSFL Performance of the Year - Richard D'Attoria V (co- with Wolfie McDummy)
NSFL Offensive Player of the Year - Ludiculo Bigby
NSFL Defensive Player of the Year - Richard D'Attoria V
Most Dedicated Member - ADwyer87
NSFL Most Valuable Player - Franklin Armstrong
Didn't Nail It
DSFL Punter of the Year
Winner: Silver Banana
My Pick: Diego Espinosa
Difference of 1.5 Yards Per Punt vs. 5 Inside the 20. Either way is fine.
DSFL Linebacker of the Year
Winner: Willie B. Hardagain
My Pick: Marlo Smart
Hardagain had the edge in PDs, but Smart had him matched or beaten everywhere else, particularly with 43 more tackles. But, he's IA which turned off some voters and which I didn't really consider too heavily.
DSFL Defensive Rookie of the Year
Winner: Galf Wilf
My Pick: Kyle Idlewyld
Wilf had a nice season no doubt, so I can't kill this too much. But I would give it to the defensive lineman of the year over the player I would have as 3rd in LB of the year
DSFL Offensive Player of the Year
Winner: Jay Cue
My Pick: Darrel Williams
Cue is obviously a DSFL monster, but 1700 yards on 5.3 average is no joke. This is fine though.
NSFL Tight End of the Year
Winner: Johnny Blaze
My Pick: Jammerson Irving
I know I was being a little wacky with this pick anyway, I'm not surprised at all with Blaze winning.
NSFL Wide Receiver of the Year
Winner: Errol Maddox
My Pick: Sunnycursed
Super close. This was debated heavily in the original post. You really can go either way depending on what you personally look for in a WR.
NSFL Defensive Rookie of the Year
Winner: Mack Arianlacher
My Pick: Stuart Little IV
Mack was good for sure, but I actually would have had him third in this race behind Lazer-Eyes as well. So it's not appalling, but the one I disagree with most, other than...
DSFL Tight End of the Year
Winner: Jean-Baptist Boivin
My Pick: DeMarcus Strike
I don't get it. Is it because Strike is in the index as FB? That didn't stop Blaze. Is it because Strike is IA? So is Boivin. Strike's numbers are basically double Boivin's. What am I missing?
---
So I got 25 out of 33 correct. Voters clearly have no idea what they're doing, except when they do.
*The Awards Committee Review - moonlight - 01-12-2020
I hope you do this every season! Fun reads
*The Awards Committee Review - SabaDonutMan - 01-12-2020
I also agree with the strike thing, I voted for an active because I was told to. So I didn’t understand when a ia te who played worse than strike won the award over him.
*The Awards Committee Review - Mooty99 - 01-13-2020
What happened to returner of the year? It was on the voting sheet but not in the broadcast and the sig for it is from S17?
*The Awards Committee Review - infinitempg - 01-13-2020
(01-13-2020, 08:43 AM)Mooty99 Wrote:What happened to returner of the year? It was on the voting sheet but not in the broadcast and the sig for it is from S17?
It didn’t fit on the screen. Forrest Gump actually won but i accidentally uploaded S17s
*The Awards Committee Review - infinitempg - 01-13-2020
(01-13-2020, 08:43 AM)Mooty99 Wrote:What happened to returner of the year? It was on the voting sheet but not in the broadcast and the sig for it is from S17?
It didn’t fit on the screen. Forrest Gump actually won but i accidentally uploaded S17s
*The Awards Committee Review - Mooty99 - 01-13-2020
(01-13-2020, 04:00 PM)infinitempg Wrote:It didn’t fit on the screen. Forrest Gump actually won but i accidentally uploaded S17s
Thanks. I voted for @UpperNet best kick return average, and did it as a LB
*The Awards Committee Review - TomHanks - 01-13-2020
(01-12-2020, 03:06 PM)SabaDonutMan Wrote:I also agree with the strike thing, I voted for an active because I was told to. So I didn’t understand when a ia te who played worse than strike won the award over him.
#JusticeForKenobi smh best active TE
*The Awards Committee Review - SabaDonutMan - 01-13-2020
(01-13-2020, 11:25 AM)TomHanks Wrote:#JusticeForKenobi smh best active TE
I did actually vote for kenobi