International Simulation Football League
*Class of S27 Rookie Class Review and Arbitrary Ranking - Printable Version

+- International Simulation Football League (https://forums.sim-football.com)
+-- Forum: Community (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Media (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=37)
+---- Forum: Graded Articles (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=38)
+---- Thread: *Class of S27 Rookie Class Review and Arbitrary Ranking (/showthread.php?tid=28984)



*Class of S27 Rookie Class Review and Arbitrary Ranking - AgentSmith - 01-12-2021

S27 Rookie Season Review and Arbitrary Ranking
Part 2/3

Part 1 can be found HERE!
Part 3 can be found HERE!

Hello ISFL, and welcome back to part 2 of 3 of the Class of Season 27 Rookie Season Review and Draft Class Arbitrary Ranking! In this section of this piece, I’ll be covering Tight Ends, Cornerbacks, and Linebackers. As a reminder of the process, I have taken game stats for all the rookies who have more than 50 TPE, through the end of the regular season, and used them to create an arbitrary score that reflects how the player performs in their given roles. I’ve broken out the class into their respective positions so that we’re not comparing Offensive and Defensive players, like QB’s (who have a higher score overall due to the possibility of both passing and rushing stats) and Offensive Linemen, who only have a few stats with which to judge them on. 

Here’s a review of my methodology. As a reminder, positions with fewer stats will have lower scores, so it shouldn’t be used as a comparison or an overall ranking (though one of the tabs in the linked spreadsheet has all players sorted by score). That spreadsheet can be found at the link below.


SPREADSHEET

For Offensive players (QB, RB, WR, TE, OL), the “Formula” is as follows:

((Completions + Passing Yards + QB Rating + Passing TDs + Rushing Attempts + Rushing Yards + Rushing TDs + Catches + Receiving Average + Receiving TDs + Pancakes) - Interceptions - Sacks Allowed) / (Games Played + 1)

For Defensive players (CB, LB, S, DE, DT), the formula is shorter, but follows the same logic:

(Tackles + Tackles for Loss + Sacks + Interceptions + Passes Defended + Safeties + Touchdowns) / (Games Played + 1)

Here we go!


Tight Ends

1. Shane Benjamin - @TheMemeMaestro - Vertical Threat - 129 TPE - 40.93
53 Catches, 553 yards, 2 TDs, 9 Pancakes, 1 Sack Allowed
The top TE in the class by this ranking is Benjamin, who had the most Receiving yards (and second highest Yards per Catch average) of the group and 2 TDs, in addition to 9 pancakes. Being a Vertical Threat means that he’s hoping to be more of a downfield option than helping to provide support on the O-Line, which would likely explain his lower numbers there. Benjamin was a part of a Portland Pythons team that steamrolled their way through the season, and while his modest 129 TPE is likely less than the Pythons management was hoping for, they can’t really be upset at his performance this season.

2. James Wilkinson - @treant - Balanced Tight End - 265 TPE - 39.40
52 Catches, 507 Yards, 1 TD, 22 Pancakes, 0 Sacks Allowed
Wilkinson has the second most TPE in the class, but falls to second in the TE list due to having the 3rd most Receiving Yards among the rookies, and he doesn’t fall lower due to his excellent performance at the line of scrimmage, putting up 22 pancakes and not allowing any sacks on the season, which is pretty impressive for a TE. Picked up by the relocated Buccaneers team, Wilkinson helped them progress to the playoffs as the first seed in the SFC South in their first season playing from Bondi Beach. Don’t be surprised if he’s picked up in the first round in this ISFL draft, his TPE and his stats speak for themselves for how good of a player he is.

3. Borgo San Lorenzo - @AgentSmith - Vertical Threat - 210 TPE - 38.53
43 Catches, 533 Yards, 2 TDs, 0 Pancakes, 0 Sacks Allowed
San Lorenzo played solely as a Wide Receiver for the Dallas Birddogs this season, which is why he didn’t record any Offensive Line stats. This allowed the Birddogs rookie QB to have an extra target to throw to whenever he wasn’t handing the ball off to Cobra Kai. With the highest yards per catch average among rookie TEs at 12.4 (also the 3rd highest among all rookies with receiving stats), San Lorenzo was always a threat to the opposing defenses, allowing him to play out his dream of being an offensive threat for a team that needed one to help relieve some pressure off the back of Kai. His TPE puts him at 22nd in the class, but rumor has it he’s expecting an influx of cash soon to hopefully be able to afford his equipment for the season, which would boost him considerably. Look for San Lorenzo to continue his pass catching ways for a team that needs that extra punch in their offensive arsenal in the next season or two.

4. Vilhjálmur Kueblerson - @benELF - Balanced Tight End - 66 TPE - 21.13
35 Catches, 204 Yards, 1 TD, 10 Pancakes, 0 Sacks Allowed
Kueblerson has the lowest amount of TPE in this group of rookies, but that didn’t stop him from performing well for the Norfolk SeaWolves this season, helping them squeeze into the playoffs with a total of 204 yards, a TD, and 10 pancakes on the season. While his name is rather eye-catching, most GMs would likely prefer his activity to be more so, his last update being the middle of December means he hasn’t been gone for long, but even so, being 51st in a class of 56 doesn’t look great. If he can come back and earn some more, Kueblerson could be an excellent late round addition to a team looking for sneaky offensive power.

5. Bobby Tarantino - @jsteele14 - Balanced Tight End - 133 TPE - 14.80
22 Catches, 192 Yards, 0 TD, 9 Pancakes, 1 Sack Allowed
Tarantino suffered in production like a lot of Minnesota did, having to play in the shadow of rookie standout Madison Hayes. With only 192 yards in 22 catches (4th best average out of 5 rookie TEs), it’s hard to get a good read on how he would have performed if allowed to play in a different system. The O-Line play from Tarantino also left a little to be desired, as compared to the other TEs in the class, his 9 pancakes and 1 sack are lackluster when he doesn’t also have the downfield stats to help balance it out. If Hayes goes to the ISFL next season it’s possible that we see a more engaging performance from Tarantino.


Cornerbacks

1. Buck Nekkid - @Voltaqe - Man to Man - 164 TPE - 5.20
61 Tackles, 0 TFL, 0 Sacks, 0/0 FF/FR, 3 INT, 14 PD
Nekkid was tied for the most tackles among rookie cornerbacks, but he also stood out by grabbing 3 interceptions (also tied for the lead among rookies) and 14 Passes Defended. His TPE earning lands him at 25th in the class, making him an attractive prospect in the second round for teams looking for a man coverage ball hawk with excellent tackling skills. If he can get his TPE up to a more competitive level after the draft, Nekkid could be a dark horse late round pick if he can continue to perform at this level.

2. Lawrence Miller - @overdoo - All-Around - 250 TPE - 4.80
57 Tackles, 0 TFL, 0 Sacks, 0/0 FF/FR, 3 INT, 12 PD
With 250 TPE, Miller ranks at 5th in the class, and with 57 tackles, 3 interceptions, and 12 passes defended, he ranks as the second best CB. Speaking from experience, Overdoo is a pleasure to have in any locker room, so not only is he a fantastic earner, but his player is racking up the stats that will make him attractive to most if not all ISFL teams. Expect Miller to be off the board somewhere in the first round, as a player with this much potential only comes once every few seasons.

3. Cayson Nzeocha - @RainDelay - Man to Man - 99 TPE - 4.80
61 Tackles, 0 TFL, 0 Sacks, 0/0 FF/FR, 0 INT, 11 PD
Nzeocha is a slow earner (99 TPE puts him at 40th in the class), but he still put up an impressive 61 tackles and 11 passes defended. Nzeocha is also the only CB in this class to not have an interception this season. Unfortunately, while his stats might be attractive, the speed of his earning will turn many ISFL GMs away from him on draft day, and it wouldn’t be surprising to see him be a very late round pickup, assuming GMs can get in touch with him to ensure he’s not just straight up inactive (he was last seen on December 7th).

4. Kita Chiasa - @Sabremike - Man to Man - 225 TPE - 4.67
57 Tackles, 0 TFL, 0 Sack, 0/0 FF/FR, 2 INT, 11 PD
Chiasa is the 12th ranked rookie in this class TPE wise, but he falls to 4th in the CB ranking due to mediocre numbers during the regular season compared to the others in this list. 57 tackles, 11 passes defended and 2 interceptions aren’t bad numbers, but he was outperformed in most areas by the top three. His earning makes him an attractive late first or early second round target for a team that is looking for a solid if not outstanding man coverage corner (at least stat wise).

5. James Bradshaw - @Gumbaman - All-Around - 166 TPE - 4.40
54 Tackles, 0 TFL, 0 Sacks, 0/0 FF/FR, 2 INT, 9 PD
Bradshaw is one of two rookie Cornerbacks to have scored a touchdown this season, and impressive feat when recording only 2 interceptions on the season. While his earning could be better compared to the rest of this position (2 of whom rank inside the top 5 in TPE), he’s not super far behind. Gumbaman is also a known quantity in most of the ISFL as a recreate, so he’s already got the connections and relationships to not be a risk factor like a first time player with the same TPE level might be.

6. Jonasredfyld Gabjonson - @nour - All-Around - 57 TPE - 4.07
52 Tackles, 0 TFL, 1 Sack, 2/2 FF/FR, 3 INT, 3 PD
While there hasn’t been an update for this Gabjohnson since just after creation, he’s performed incredibly well. 52 Tackles, the only rookie CB with a sack, 2 forced fumbles and 2 recoveries, 3 interceptions, and even 2 touchdowns. His only lowlight is his passes defended, where he only has 3. If nour can come back and get an update in, it will be extremely interesting to see in Gabjonson can continue his dominance in the secondary for Bondi Beach next season, as he won’t be going to the ISFL anytime soon with only 57 TPE.

7. HeHateMe PickSix II - @Vorshayla - Zone - 253 TPE - 3.93
44 Tackles, 1 TFL, 0 Sacks, 2/0 FF/FR, 1 INT, 13 PD
Many will have PickSix II at the top of their draft board, but since the scores in this article are assigned based on stats, he ends up as the second to last rookie corner in the class, even while having earned the 3rd most TPE. With only 44 tackles, he is far behind his classmates, even with his 13 passes defended and an interception. He’s the only Zone Corner in this class, and also the only CB here to have recorded a Tackle for Loss, and 1 of 2 to have forced fumbles (an important stat but not included in the calculation because of laziness). While he ranks low here, look for him to be a top 5 pick in the coming draft.

8. Dash Smith - @bruhbruhbruh - All-Around - 79 TPE - 3.14
37 Tackles, 0 TFL, 0 Sacks, 0/0 FF/FR, 1 INT, 6 PD
Smith came in as a late create for the Dallas Birddogs, so he only has 13 games under his belt to the rest of the class’s 14. Add that to only 37 tackles, 6 passes defended and an interception, and we have the lowest score for the rookie CBs. It doesn’t help that he’s also only earned 79 TPE, putting him at 47th in the class. It wouldn’t be a surprise to see a team pick him up late in the draft just in case he comes back, but it doesn’t look promising, as he hasn’t been on the site since the middle of December.


Linebackers

1. Duke Cheeks - @TropicaliaCC - Speed Rusher - 238 TPE - 7.47
98 Tackles, 7 TFL, 4/2 FF/FR, 1 Sack, 6 PD
Cheeks was 2 behind the rookie leader in tackles, tied for first in tackles for loss and passes defended, had one sack, and forced four fumbles (unfortunately not counted in the score, due to laziness), making his stat line easily the most impressive in this batch of linebackers. With 238 TPE, Cheeks rounds out the top 10 of the TPE ranking, making him extremely attractive as a choice in the first round for a team that needs to add some pressure in their opponent’s backfield. The Royals can only hope he gets to play with them for one more season and put up these kinds of numbers again.

2. Kevin Morrison - @thecanadiancanuck - Power Rusher - 223 TPE - 7.15
100 Tackles, 3 TFL, 0/0 FF/FR, 1 Sack, 4 PD
Morrison led all rookies in tackles, breaking an impressive 100, which also puts him at 11th in the league. Three tackles for loss, a sack, and 4 passes defended give him enough to be put as the second linebacker in this class. With the third most TPE among the rookie linebackers, he’s 13th in the class, showing dedication to earning and would be a good addition to a linebacking corps that needs a threat to the running game and the opposing quarterback.

3. Demetre Elliot - @Retuperkele - Coverage Linebacker - 101 TPE - 6.93
98 Tackles, 0 TFL, 1/1 FF/FR. 0 Sacks, 6 PD
Elliot was tied with Cheeks with 98 tackles on the season, but didn’t record any tackles for loss or sacks, but that makes sense, as he played as a coverage linebacker instead of a rusher. His 6 passes defended are tied for first (also with Cheeks), showing his effectiveness. His earning has fallen behind a large portion of the class; he ranks at 39th in the class. If he can pick up his earnings in the next season or two, he could be a good late round pick for a team that needs a little help in pass coverage, as I’m sure Dallas would love to have him back to do next season.

4. Jim The Vampire - @Kyle - Speed Rusher - 250 TPE - 6.60
89 Tackles, 1 TFL, 0/0 FF/FR, 5 Sacks, 4 PD
The Vampire is the spookiest rushing linebacker in the class, having recorded 5 sacks and one tackle for loss. Dallas loved having him lead the defense this season, and it’s not hard to see why, as his 89 tackles put him in the upper half of linebackers in the league, and his TPE has him at 6th in the class. It won’t be surprising to have The Vampire on an ISFL roster next season, likely with a pick in the first round, but I’m sure Dallas would love to have him back in their secondary in S28.

5. Devonte Crook - @Southie - Speed Rusher - 198 TPE - 5.13
68 Tackles, 4 TFL, 0/0 FF/FR, 4 Sacks, 1 PD
Crook’s 68 tackles, 4 tackles for loss, 4 sacks, and 1 pass defended were respectable for the 5th ranked linebacker in this rookie class, and his TPE number places him at 25th in the class. If he had been a little more productive for the Luchadores, he might have been ranked a little higher, but since only stats matter here, he falls down the list a little bit.

6. Benjamin Ankers - @SirBongo - Speed Rusher - 103 TPE - 4.40
51 Tackles, 7 TFL, 1/2 FF/FR, 3 Sacks, 5 PD
Ankers is the final linebacker in this class, and even though he recorded an impressive 7 tackles for loss, 3 sacks, 5 pases defended, 1 forced fumble, and 2 fumble recoveries, his 51 tackles on the season means he ranks last in this position group. His 103 TPE puts him at 37th in the class, which means he’ll likely return next season for the SeaWolves unless the team that drafts him is really desperate for some pressure in the backfield.


Part 1 can be found HERE!
Part 3 can be found HERE!

Code:
~2650 Words



RE: Class of S27 Rookie Class Review and Arbitrary Ranking - Voltaqe - 01-12-2021

#1 CB! MOM I MADE IT!


RE: *Class of S27 Rookie Class Review and Arbitrary Ranking - RainDelay - 01-17-2021

Slow earner no longer. GMs know what I'm capable of!