International Simulation Football League
*NSFL Starting Roster Ranks PT1 - Printable Version

+- International Simulation Football League (https://forums.sim-football.com)
+-- Forum: Community (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Media (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=37)
+---- Forum: Graded Statistical Analysis (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=153)
+---- Thread: *NSFL Starting Roster Ranks PT1 (/showthread.php?tid=3625)

*NSFL Starting Roster Ranks PT1 - BrotherP - 08-23-2017

Each of these rankings is based on the rating given by the simulator in relative mode where it compares the players to the other players in the league.

I have done half of the teams so far and I will try to do the rest. Then I am going to do this with actual TPE earned instead of ratings.

I am not sure how important overall ratings are in the end but I think basd on these results they have some importance.

The rankings are based on a system like the one ProFootballFocus uses. I went through and checked the ratings of every player, ranked them into the categories and then made the graphics.

The Las Vegas Legion have a roster that breaks down as follows:

Elite- 3
Good- 2
Above Average- 4
Average-3
Below Average- 7
Liability- 6

[Image: KEAEXsb.png]

The San Jose SaberCats have a roster that breaks down as follows:

Elite- 4
Good- 4
Above Average- 2
Average- 7
Below Average- 7
Liability- 1

[Image: 7e6k7hX.png]

The Orange County Otters have a roster that breaks down as follows:

Elite- 6
Good- 3
Above Average- 6
Average- 2
Below Average- 6
Liability- 2

[Image: 1QN528j.png]

The Arizona Outlaws have a roster that breaks down as follows:

Elite- 11
Good- 3
Above Average- 4
Average- 4
Below Average- 2
Liability- 1

[Image: lT0mGPo.png]

I do not know what is the best way to build a player in the seem or how good the overall rankings really are (I have a brother for that) but based on these results the overall rankings has some impact. The teams with the best overall ranked players are doing the best and the teams with the worst are doing the worst.

I will do more spins on this information by positions, comparing all teams, and more in the future. Thank you for reading.

*NSFL Starting Roster Ranks PT1 - ErMurazor - 08-23-2017

I think you mixed up yourself and Mackworthy ya dummy.

*NSFL Starting Roster Ranks PT1 - Bzerkap - 08-23-2017

(08-23-2017, 09:24 PM)ErMurazor Wrote:I think you mixed up yourself and Mackworthy ya dummy.
Brotherly love

*NSFL Starting Roster Ranks PT1 - Sweetwater - 08-23-2017

Curious as to how you got your rankings. Obviously I'm not looking for your exact formula. But I'm curious what makes Ja Brill a 100 ranking, but me (John Canton) an 86, despite me having more TPE, and more defensive plays/stats than him?

*NSFL Starting Roster Ranks PT1 - BrotherP - 08-25-2017

(08-23-2017, 08:24 PM)Sweetwater Wrote:Curious as to how you got your rankings. Obviously I'm not looking for your exact formula. But I'm curious what makes Ja Brill a 100 ranking, but me (John Canton) an 86, despite me having more TPE, and more defensive plays/stats than him?

I just took each of these from the game.

*NSFL Starting Roster Ranks PT1 - Bzerkap - 08-25-2017

(08-23-2017, 10:24 PM)Sweetwater Wrote:Curious as to how you got your rankings. Obviously I'm not looking for your exact formula. But I'm curious what makes Ja Brill a 100 ranking, but me (John Canton) an 86, despite me having more TPE, and more defensive plays/stats than him?
His OP says it is a comparative ranking. From the sim

*NSFL Starting Roster Ranks PT1 - Sweetwater - 08-25-2017

(08-25-2017, 08:13 PM)BrotherP Wrote:I just took each of these from the game.

Gotcha, missed the part where you said it was in relative mode. Saw the PFF style and thought you had added some formulation.