+- International Simulation Football League (https://forums.sim-football.com)
+-- Forum: Community (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Discussion (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=33)
+---- Forum: Suggestion Box (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=34)
+----- Forum: Archived Suggestions (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=349)
+----- Thread: Out of position penalty (/showthread.php?tid=4936)
Out of position penalty - kckolbe - 09-27-2017
The two leading tacklers in the league are safeties playing at LB. When it was Verns I didn't think much of it. Dude was a high TPE player. But now Torque Lewith? The speed cap for safety makes them better for LB, since strength appears to mean pretty much nothing when tackling (source: Lewith bringing down Jenkins ALL NIGHT on Friday).
Just as CB was adjusted because S was better at CB than CB was, should we look at changing something here? Again, not only are they at the top...it's kinda not even close.
Out of position penalty - tlk742 - 09-27-2017
I think if that's going to be applied then should there be finite number of position changes a player can go through?
Out of position penalty - kckolbe - 09-27-2017
(09-27-2017, 09:34 PM)tlk742 Wrote:I think if that's going to be applied then should there be finite number of position changes a player can go through?
These aren't players changing position, just playing out of position as their primary role.
Out of position penalty - tlk742 - 09-27-2017
(09-27-2017, 11:36 PM)kckolbe Wrote:These aren't players changing position, just playing out of position as their primary role.Sure, but if you let's say put a penalty on torque, he now can't do anything what with the cap on position changes.
Out of position penalty - Muford - 09-27-2017
If that's the case, shouldn't Bork also then not be playing Defensive Tackle? It's crazy that a DE is getting those kind of stats slotted in the defensive tackle position.
EDIT:
Most Defensive Tackles Max Speeds are 65, yet Bork Bjornsson is sitting at 80, slotted in DT. If you don't like safeties playing LB, then DEs shouldn't play DT
Out of position penalty - cosbornballboy - 09-27-2017
(09-27-2017, 08:41 PM)Muford Wrote:If that's the case, shouldn't Bork also then not be playing Defensive Tackle? It's crazy that a DE is getting those kind of stats slotted in the defensive tackle position.
EDIT:
Most Defensive Tackles Max Speeds are 65, yet Bork Bjornsson is sitting at 80, slotted in DT. If you don't like safeties playing LB, then DEs shouldn't play DT
Yo true. That's some mad BS
Out of position penalty - loco - 09-28-2017
(09-27-2017, 08:41 PM)Muford Wrote:If that's the case, shouldn't Bork also then not be playing Defensive Tackle? It's crazy that a DE is getting those kind of stats slotted in the defensive tackle position.maybe we could add a
EDIT:
Most Defensive Tackles Max Speeds are 65, yet Bork Bjornsson is sitting at 80, slotted in DT. If you don't like safeties playing LB, then DEs shouldn't play DT
wait for it
out of position penalty
remember it here, i thought of it first
no one else would think of this
or even make it the title of the thread we're replying in
Out of position penalty - Daybe - 09-28-2017
(09-27-2017, 09:41 PM)Muford Wrote:If that's the case, shouldn't Bork also then not be playing Defensive Tackle? It's crazy that a DE is getting those kind of stats slotted in the defensive tackle position.
EDIT:
Most Defensive Tackles Max Speeds are 65, yet Bork Bjornsson is sitting at 80, slotted in DT. If you don't like safeties playing LB, then DEs shouldn't play DT
that was in fact the exact reason why Bjornsson switched iirc
Out of position penalty - Muford - 09-28-2017
(09-27-2017, 11:22 PM)loco Wrote:maybe we could add a
wait for it
out of position penalty
remember it here, i thought of it first
no one else would think of this
or even make it the title of the thread we're replying in
No shit, but I'm just stating that he's talking specifically about the LBs right now, but fails to mention his own teammate in it. Doesn't that seem a little off?
EDIT: I'm just saying, if your coming for 1 position, you need to come for them all, and not just single out this example of Lewith and Verns
Out of position penalty - Bzerkap - 09-28-2017
(09-27-2017, 11:29 PM)Muford Wrote:No shit, but I'm just stating that he's talking specifically about the LBs right now, but fails to mention his own teammate in it. Doesn't that seem a little off?I think he only mentioned LB because that's his position so he follows those stats closely. If you asked him he would agree about DE and DT. Many people have talked about it and that's why you see everyone switching to run stopper. Watch @loco rack up huge stats the rest of the season as a DE playing DT