+- International Simulation Football League (https://forums.sim-football.com)
+-- Forum: Community (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Media (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=37)
+---- Forum: Graded Articles (https://forums.sim-football.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=38)
+---- Thread: How ChatGPT ranks the ISFL Rookie QBs Through 11 Games (/showthread.php?tid=52585)
How ChatGPT ranks the ISFL Rookie QBs Through 11 Games - soevil - 08-06-2024
Disclaimer: I simply provided the statistics (passing, rushing, and combined) for each of the 5 rookie quarterbacks (Jimmies, O'Duck, Dyson, Zamolodchikova, and Bugs) and asked it to rank the them for placement as ISFLs Rookie Quarterback of the Year award. Here is the result.
1. Russell Jimmies -
• Total Yards: 2703
• Total Touchdowns: 18 (13 Passing, 5 Rushing)
• Total Turnovers: 9 (5 INT, 4 FUM)
• Completion Percentage: 66.8%
• Yards Per Attempt: Not provided
• Rating: 89.9
• Rushing Average: 4.8
• Sacks: 31
• Record: 6-5
2. Elijah Dyson -
• Total Yards: 2560
• Total Touchdowns: 19 (14 Passing, 5 Rushing)
• Total Turnovers: 6 (4 INT, 2 FUM)
• Completion Percentage: 59.7%
• Yards Per Attempt: Not provided
• Rating: 92.5
• Rushing Average: 4.1
• Sacks: 31
• Record: 5-6
3. Puddles O’Duck -
• Total Yards: 2386
• Total Touchdowns: 19
• Total Turnovers: 8 (4 INT, 4 FUM)
• Completion Percentage: 64%
• Yards Per Attempt: Not provided
• Rating: 97.8
• Rushing Average: Not provided
• Sacks: 38
• Record: 5-6
4. Katya Zamolodchikova -
• Total Yards: 2512
• Total Touchdowns: 5
• Total Turnovers: 11 (8 INT, 3 FUM)
• Completion Percentage: 60%
• Yards Per Attempt: Not provided
• Rating: 71.4
• Rushing Average: Not provided
• Sacks: 44
• Record: 1-10
5. Bugs -
• Total Yards: 2819
• Total Touchdowns: 15
• Total Turnovers: 8 (4 INT, 4 FUM)
• Completion Percentage: 60.8%
• Yards Per Attempt: Not provided
• Rating: 90.5
• Rushing Average: Not provided
• Sacks: 50
• Record: 7-4
Analysis:
1. Total Yards: Bugs leads with 2819 yards, followed by Jimmies with 2703. Total yards are a good indicator of offensive production.
2. Total Touchdowns: Dyson and O’Duck are tied with 19 touchdowns, which is the highest among the group.
3. Total Turnovers: Dyson has the fewest turnovers (6), followed by O’Duck (8) and Bugs (8). Fewer turnovers are typically better.
4. Completion Percentage: Jimmies leads with a 66.8% completion rate, indicating high accuracy.
5. Quarterback Rating: O’Duck has the highest rating (97.8), reflecting overall efficiency.
6. Record: Bugs has the best record (7-4), indicating team success.
Based on the provided metrics and their overall impact, here is a ranking of the quarterbacks from 1 to 5 for a Rookie QB of the Year award:
1. Puddles O’Duck -
o Rating: 97.8 (Highest)
o Total Touchdowns: 19 (Tied for highest)
o Completion Percentage: 64% (4th)
o Total Yards: 2386 (4th)
o Total Turnovers: 8 (3rd)
o Record: 5-6 (Tied for 2nd)
Why: O’Duck leads in quarterback rating, showing the highest efficiency. Despite fewer total yards and touchdowns, the high rating and relatively good touchdown-to-turnover ratio make them the top choice.
2. Bugs -
o Total Yards: 2819 (Highest)
o Total Touchdowns: 15 (4th)
o Completion Percentage: 60.8% (5th)
o Rating: 90.5 (3rd)
o Total Turnovers: 8 (Tied for 2nd)
o Record: 7-4 (Best)
Why: Bugs leads in total yards and has the best record, indicating strong overall impact and effectiveness. However, slightly lower efficiency and fewer touchdowns place them second.
3. Russell Jimmies -
o Total Yards: 2703 (2nd)
o Total Touchdowns: 18 (2nd)
o Completion Percentage: 66.8% (Highest)
o Rating: 89.9 (4th)
o Total Turnovers: 9 (4th)
o Record: 6-5 (3rd)
Why: Jimmies boasts the highest completion percentage and strong total yards and touchdowns. Despite a good record and solid efficiency, they fall slightly behind due to a lower rating and turnover count.
4. Elijah Dyson -
o Total Yards: 2560 (3rd)
o Total Touchdowns: 19 (Tied for highest)
o Completion Percentage: 59.7% (4th)
o Rating: 92.5 (2nd)
o Total Turnovers: 6 (Lowest)
o Record: 5-6 (Tied for 2nd)
Why: Dyson has the lowest number of turnovers and a high rating, reflecting efficiency. However, their lower completion percentage, fewer yards, and touchdowns place them in the fourth spot.
5. Katya Zamolodchikova -
o Total Yards: 2512 (4th)
o Total Touchdowns: 5 (Lowest)
o Completion Percentage: 60% (5th)
o Rating: 71.4 (Lowest)
o Total Turnovers: 11 (Highest)
o Record: 1-10 (Worst)
Why: Zamolodchikova has the lowest rating, fewest touchdowns, and the worst record. While the total yards are decent, the high number of turnovers and overall poor performance make them the lowest ranked.
This ranking balances individual efficiency, overall production, and team success to determine the best quarterback for the award.
So what do you think? How do these rookies stack up? I know I am excited to see how the rest of the season shakes up. I would have liked to have included strength of schedule among other metrics but ain't nobody got time for that.
RE: How ChatGPT ranks the ISFL Rookie QBs Through 11 Games - Big Edd - 08-06-2024
JIMMIES
RE: How ChatGPT ranks the ISFL Rookie QBs Through 11 Games - juniped - 08-06-2024
I'm using this for the draft so you know