(4/5 - $1m) Overall, I just want to say this is fantastic work that you've done here to create this. I'm usually not a huge fan of non-football renders, because they usually seem to be much more difficult to work with and edit for sigs and player graphics. But, you really made this one work, and it's actually a huge reason for why it's so good. Having Spiderman on top of the name was a great idea, and that small amount of shading underneath him a really nice detail that not everyone would notice, unless it wasn't there. The graphic itself is just awesome. Although, you probably noticed that you didn't get a 5/5, and there is a reason for that. A 5/5 is generally saved for those few high quality graphics that have no issues and really "pop" and stand out to anyone that looks at it. The biggest issue with this sig is that "pop" factor. The scale of that background compared to the graphic itself is huge. Because of this, when you look at it, your eyes kind of get lost in the sig, because there's just so much open space around the really important elements of the overall graphic. I don't think a GIF background is necessarily a bad choice; it just needs to find the right balance of adding something to the graphic without distracting from everything else. Really great work though!