3/5: Very good render work. Not a huge fan of the flame effect. The biggest problem is the text with this one. I don't like the font selection, they are too light for a sig. Also the effects around the text isn't super good. If you can fix the text (which is a very hard thing to do) this could easily become a 4.
4/5: Again very good render work! The text is way better on this one. Not a huge fan of the blending of the logo. This one could become a 5 with some effects going around the render. (Also this looks a lot like my earlier work, which makes me happy