(02-28-2022, 10:13 AM)mithrandir Wrote: If LB is mafia and we kill him, then the mafia roles with killing ability would just pass to someone else, if I understand correctly. Maybe we should just role block him instead.
i'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you're new to this game, so i won't immediately place suspicion on you
BUT if we identify a mafia, we have to lynch it. The goal is to whittle down all of these evils. LB would be mafioso in this case, or godfather (gf) because we are playing all any. That means the next mafia member would lose their special mafia ability and turn into a mafioso, which is a pretty weak role compared to gf or whatever role they just had
one is a medusa, can only do stone gaze twice more, so they wont necessarily kill anyone who visits them tonight.
one is a potion master - who has used their attacking potion already, meaning they won't be able to use it again for 3 nights.
the other two could be anything else, but probably not potion master.
necromancers can use dead players abilities, but no killing roles have died so we should be safe, but idk how using an amnesiac would work tbh. There could be a poisoner who's poisoned someone, so they would end up dying tmrw.
hex masters won't matter until they get the necronomicon simply because we have too mnay players
coven leaders can control people, so we shouldn't have to worry too much about that yet since we don't know any vigilantes
Coven is the deadliest faction, and can kill more people than mafia, so it's important to understand what they could do and which positions we should target. Once they get necronomicon on night three, they'll be much more deadly.
and qWest could have been any member, mafia / neutral / townie
(02-28-2022, 10:13 AM)mithrandir Wrote: If LB is mafia and we kill him, then the mafia roles with killing ability would just pass to someone else, if I understand correctly. Maybe we should just role block him instead.
i'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you're new to this game, so i won't immediately place suspicion on you
BUT if we identify a mafia, we have to lynch it. The goal is to whittle down all of these evils. LB would be mafioso in this case, or godfather (gf) because we are playing all any. That means the next mafia member would lose their special mafia ability and turn into a mafioso, which is a pretty weak role compared to gf or whatever role they just had
Yes, this is my first time playing. I thought blocking might be a better strategy than killing right away but I don't really know much about the game yet.