*AI Ranks all the Rookie QBs

soevil

The previous ranking through week 11:

1. O'Duck ARI

2. Bugs

3. Jimmies OSK

4. Dyson

Below I will include the prompt used to generate the response and then the summaries of each of rookie quarterbacks. I simply took the statistics from the advanced stats sheet and asked it to rank the quarterbacks 1-4.

Code:
Please review the data in the table provided below and rank the quarterbacks from best to worst and provide a summary explaining your reasoning. Please carefully review all data points when performing calculations. 

EDIT: I tried to include the complete table but it looks wonky af. Here is the list of metrics included from the stat table:

Player | PassAtt | PassCmp | PassPct | PassYds | PassTD | TD% | PassInt | INT% | TD/INT | Pass20 | Pass40 | PassFD% | WasSacked | Sack% | RushAtt | RushYds |YPC | RushTD | FumblesLost | TO% | TD% | Total Yards | Total TDs | PassRating | Y/G | Y/C | Y/A | AY/A | NY/A | ANY/A | TANY/A |

1. Russell Jimmies OSK

Russell Jimmies is ranked first due to his impressive overall performance, particularly in accuracy and ball security. He leads with the highest Completion Percentage (66.00%) and boasts the lowest Turnover Percentage, which highlights his effectiveness in minimizing mistakes. Jimmies also has a strong Total Yards figure, showcasing his ability to advance the ball efficiently. Although his Total Touchdowns are fewer compared to some other quarterbacks, his combination of high completion rate and low turnover rate secures his top position.

2. Elijah Dyson NYS

Elijah Dyson ranks second with a well-rounded performance. He is notable for his low Turnover Percentage, indicating effective ball management, and his Touchdown Percentage is among the higher figures. However, Dyson is ranked third in Total Yards, which slightly affects his standing compared to others with higher yardage totals. Despite this, his ability to accumulate yardage and his strong scoring rate place him as the second-best quarterback.

3. Puddles O'Duck ARI

Puddles O'Duck is ranked third due to his strengths in Touchdown Percentage and Completion Percentage. However, his performance is less impressive in Total Yards, where he ranks the lowest, and his Total Turnovers are higher than those of the top-ranked players. These factors, combined with his decent efficiency in scoring and completion, contribute to his position as third.

4. Bugs SAR

Bugs is ranked fourth due to several performance inconsistencies. Although he has the highest Total Yards, his Completion Percentage and Turnover Percentage are less favorable compared to his peers. His Touchdown Percentage is also lower, affecting his ability to convert yardage into scoring opportunities. The combination of high yardage but less efficient passing and higher turnovers results in Bugs being ranked fourth.

Now, I don't actually expect this to be the result of the OROY award, as the general consensus that I have seen while talking around the league is that it is likely O'Duck's award to lose (with some Bugs fanatics for some reason). I do, however, think that some credit should be given to Jimmies and Dyson as the new pioneers for the "scrambling" QBs (We're Mobile, its different!). Dyson especially, as New York's TPE total for their top 3 pass catchers was only 1669, which is just over half of what Osaka and Arizona each boasted (3173 and 2944 respectively). Honestly, I think each of the 4 rookie quarterbacks went above expectations and I am excited to see how each career plays out. Oh. One last thing. Lets just leave all awards to the sim from now on. I think they have a perfectly balanced formula:
[Image: ggKKgbv.png]