(12-02-2019, 06:07 PM)PDXBaller Wrote:As I reflect on this more, I think this is the compromise. I can see both sides and wanted to root for the awards committee, but it may not be necessary if we can remedy the issues that have been brought up.we dont necessarily have plans, but i dont think we really have anyone against it. I know in GM chat just after this thing dropped GMs talked about it and no one in that convo was opposed. I'm certainly not opposed either. THat could be a discussion we have in GM chat pretty quickly i think and have that done before week 2, and if it passes (which im sure it would) i dont think people would mind retroactively releasing the ballots to this year
Are there any plans to make the GM and HO voting open?
EDIT: just posted a vote in GM chat about this now
One thing we have done is try and move to a google form. First attempt was done openly, so everyone could see each others ballots. Second one was done closed. This takes away any chances to copy ballots, though we did have some issues with going back and editing ballots which we will work on fixing in the future.
Two things that have been brought up by both GMs and sapp2013 in an official proposal were having a 1st/2nd/3rd place voting instead of just a one person takes all vote. The other is having set candidates to vote on, like you are given 3-5 people who are nominated and we vote on those people. Personally, I like the 1st/2nd/3rd place voting, but am not a fan of having set candidates