Okay, so I'm going to do these in two groups, because they are pretty similar, but some I like a little more than the others. I'll refer to each of them as 1-5, going from top to bottom.
#1, #3, #4 (4/5 - $1m) I definitely like these ones the most. I feel like #1 (Nate Swift) is the best of the entire bunch, but not enough to really separate it grade-wise from the other two here. Overall, these are very slick, but there could definitely be some work done to them to make them even better. First, there's some render editing and jersey swapping done, but there doesn't seem to be a full swap in any of them. This isn't always a bad thing, but it definitely would've helped the overall grades if there was some more work done with them. I like the Nate Swift sig the most, because the original color of the jersey just blends really well with the rest of the sig. I also think the text on these three has a slightly better look than the other two sigs listed below, especially on #1.
#2, #5 (3.5/5 - $850k) So, the same general ideas as described above apply to these as well, but I just feel like these two could use a little more work than the others. They're still very good, but they seem rushed in a few areas, such as the lighting effects and the text. The text on #5 is almost completely covered by the lighting effect on top of it, and it kind of draws attention away from everything else. The render on #5 looks to be one of the better ones, but it just doesn't seem to be the focus of the sig with everything going on with the text. For #2, the main problems are in the background and a few areas of the render. The background looks rushed, especially around the edges. It might be the style you were going for, but it doesn't really come across that way. The render is also blurry in a few spots, specifically on the right side of his body, and his hand looks like it has like 7 fingers for some reason. This isn't a huge problem, but it's definitely a noticeable detail.
Overall payout: $4,700,000
#1, #3, #4 (4/5 - $1m) I definitely like these ones the most. I feel like #1 (Nate Swift) is the best of the entire bunch, but not enough to really separate it grade-wise from the other two here. Overall, these are very slick, but there could definitely be some work done to them to make them even better. First, there's some render editing and jersey swapping done, but there doesn't seem to be a full swap in any of them. This isn't always a bad thing, but it definitely would've helped the overall grades if there was some more work done with them. I like the Nate Swift sig the most, because the original color of the jersey just blends really well with the rest of the sig. I also think the text on these three has a slightly better look than the other two sigs listed below, especially on #1.
#2, #5 (3.5/5 - $850k) So, the same general ideas as described above apply to these as well, but I just feel like these two could use a little more work than the others. They're still very good, but they seem rushed in a few areas, such as the lighting effects and the text. The text on #5 is almost completely covered by the lighting effect on top of it, and it kind of draws attention away from everything else. The render on #5 looks to be one of the better ones, but it just doesn't seem to be the focus of the sig with everything going on with the text. For #2, the main problems are in the background and a few areas of the render. The background looks rushed, especially around the edges. It might be the style you were going for, but it doesn't really come across that way. The render is also blurry in a few spots, specifically on the right side of his body, and his hand looks like it has like 7 fingers for some reason. This isn't a huge problem, but it's definitely a noticeable detail.
Overall payout: $4,700,000