Hopefully this doesn't come off as me attacking you for this but I do want to point out a couple of things.
First off, the S archetypes are not different enough from one another to make some of the claims in the Vegeta pick review. There are some differences between them that give them different strengths, but saying we needed a S who can defend the pass assumes a specific player exists for this role, which is not really the case in our sim.
Also, just from a theory perspective, you ding us several times for not trading up, referencing that we had other picks available in the later rounds. But we could only have really done that once, and we would definitively have missed out on other valuable players in doing so. For example, Kurisuto vs Jerome Davis. Is 50 (or whatever amount) extra TPE worth not picking up more DL depth, which we desperately needed? By the time these respective players hit their peaks, that difference - if it still exists - will be functionally meaningless. Effectively trading during the NSFL draft is difficult for this specific reason.
Anyway, I very much enjoyed your willingness to be legitimately critical of picks. So many of these sorts of medias will be like 'ugh, horrible draft. B+'. Hopefully none of the rebuttals from teams discourage you from continuing to do this, though. This is just the nature of criticizing something that someone else is happy about.
First off, the S archetypes are not different enough from one another to make some of the claims in the Vegeta pick review. There are some differences between them that give them different strengths, but saying we needed a S who can defend the pass assumes a specific player exists for this role, which is not really the case in our sim.
Also, just from a theory perspective, you ding us several times for not trading up, referencing that we had other picks available in the later rounds. But we could only have really done that once, and we would definitively have missed out on other valuable players in doing so. For example, Kurisuto vs Jerome Davis. Is 50 (or whatever amount) extra TPE worth not picking up more DL depth, which we desperately needed? By the time these respective players hit their peaks, that difference - if it still exists - will be functionally meaningless. Effectively trading during the NSFL draft is difficult for this specific reason.
Anyway, I very much enjoyed your willingness to be legitimately critical of picks. So many of these sorts of medias will be like 'ugh, horrible draft. B+'. Hopefully none of the rebuttals from teams discourage you from continuing to do this, though. This is just the nature of criticizing something that someone else is happy about.