It'll be interesting to see how the HOF committee tackles this recent wave of kickers. Six kickers making the hall will be a bit much I think, so I have to wonder how much they decide to value efficiency over bulk metrics - kickers will lose efficiency as they get older, but as these kickers all had long careers how much do we expect that? I think Smalls, Small, Powers, and McDairmid will be in. Kokot will be interesting to watch as that career unfolds. I am unconvinced by Sidekick, and I'd bet he's the one to not make it.
Also, where did you get these FG efficiency metrics from? On WolfieBot, Micycle is #1 in FG PCT all time, given a minimum of 25 FG attempts. There are a few flash in the pan kickers who played half a season or a full season before being kicked to the curb that have a higher FG PCT, sure, but I don't think that's a fair assessment to make. We don't say Julian Edelman is one of the greatest playoff QBs of all time after all.
I also disagree with your assessment of the Micycle. At time of induction, being #1 in FG PCT and #2 (#1 if we don't count the multi Ronaldo) in Punt Avg. was what really got him in. The five seasons of elite kicker/punter play (including being the first kicker to have a perfect season) are arguably the only reason he was inducted - the piss-poor QB play probably convinced some voters to not vote Yes if anything.
Anyways you're awesome keep pumping these out lub u
Also, where did you get these FG efficiency metrics from? On WolfieBot, Micycle is #1 in FG PCT all time, given a minimum of 25 FG attempts. There are a few flash in the pan kickers who played half a season or a full season before being kicked to the curb that have a higher FG PCT, sure, but I don't think that's a fair assessment to make. We don't say Julian Edelman is one of the greatest playoff QBs of all time after all.
I also disagree with your assessment of the Micycle. At time of induction, being #1 in FG PCT and #2 (#1 if we don't count the multi Ronaldo) in Punt Avg. was what really got him in. The five seasons of elite kicker/punter play (including being the first kicker to have a perfect season) are arguably the only reason he was inducted - the piss-poor QB play probably convinced some voters to not vote Yes if anything.
Anyways you're awesome keep pumping these out lub u
![[Image: 55457_s.gif]](https://signavatar.com/55457_s.gif)