(02-19-2024, 01:19 PM)slate Wrote:I agree whole heartedly, what the NCAA deals with is far, far more detrimental to the league than what happened in KCC.(02-19-2024, 12:34 PM)TheRake Wrote:(02-19-2024, 12:31 PM)slate Wrote:Nope because the ISFL has idiosyncrasies that don't map 1 to 1 to real football, but we have two confounding issuing:(02-19-2024, 12:27 PM)TheRake Wrote: Most people get mad at the most logical conclusion. When college teams have ineligible players, they forfeit any wins, yes?
Is it possible for an NFL team to call up a college player the week before a game, but have the now-NFL player accidentally show up for the college team's game that weekend?
1. The punishment is unprecedented
2. The real life analog that a real sports league does, the NCAA, has issues with ineligible players all the time and the solution is vacating wins.
I disagree strongly with #2 because it isn't a meaningful real life analogue. Just because we both use the term "ineligible" to describe two vastly different circumstances doesn't mean we should just copy-paste the punishment that the NCAA uses for a violation which has nothing to do with ours.
"...TheRake may be the most controversial new player of the S41 class. Notorious not only for shamelessly tampering but also for confidently arguing his broadly incorrect NFL opinions, TheRake has managed to navigate the dangerous waters of controversy fairly well—which is no small feat!" - aeonsjenni