04-01-2024, 10:33 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-01-2024, 10:41 PM by Alikh. Edited 2 times in total.)
Submission Date 3/21/24
https://forums.sim-football.com/showthre...?tid=50379
I am confused by the extremely (imo) low grading on these. 2/5 says "Graphics that receive this grade show some effort to be more than a meme and some photo editing skill, however the changes to the render, text, and background are minimal or non-existent, and/or the original logos are still visible on the render."
Both renders have custom backgrounds with color edits to them, several layers of background to create glow effect (#1) and white to yellow gradient with the sunburst (#2) Pic #2 is a number swap, matching the wrinkle pattern of the underlying jersey. Both have the original NFL helmet logo removed and the team logo bent to the shape of the helmet. Neither jersey retains an NFL logo, both have DSFL added. Both jerseys are recolored to include two of that teams colors. Players are cut cleanly.
(example, this was just graded a 3 in the same time frame by the same grader: https://forums.sim-football.com/showthre...?tid=50445)
I would personally consider these a 4 by the rubric.
"Graphics that receive this grade are ones that we expected season veterans of graphics creation to make more often than not. The text blends with the rest of the signature, but the jersey swap (if applicable) and/or added logos may look a little off. This could also include text/font that does not blend well with the surrounding area, or a background that could still use more improvement."
https://forums.sim-football.com/showthre...?tid=50379
I am confused by the extremely (imo) low grading on these. 2/5 says "Graphics that receive this grade show some effort to be more than a meme and some photo editing skill, however the changes to the render, text, and background are minimal or non-existent, and/or the original logos are still visible on the render."
Both renders have custom backgrounds with color edits to them, several layers of background to create glow effect (#1) and white to yellow gradient with the sunburst (#2) Pic #2 is a number swap, matching the wrinkle pattern of the underlying jersey. Both have the original NFL helmet logo removed and the team logo bent to the shape of the helmet. Neither jersey retains an NFL logo, both have DSFL added. Both jerseys are recolored to include two of that teams colors. Players are cut cleanly.
(example, this was just graded a 3 in the same time frame by the same grader: https://forums.sim-football.com/showthre...?tid=50445)
I would personally consider these a 4 by the rubric.
"Graphics that receive this grade are ones that we expected season veterans of graphics creation to make more often than not. The text blends with the rest of the signature, but the jersey swap (if applicable) and/or added logos may look a little off. This could also include text/font that does not blend well with the surrounding area, or a background that could still use more improvement."