3/5700k As always I like your background work. However, this execution was a tad off. I think your smoke was of a lower resolution that didn't do well with the scaling up. It is always better to scale down than up. Next, we get to your renders. For one they don't feel apart of the background, nothing is layered with them. Your swap just adds the logo to the jersey, but we felt more could have been done. Also, the difference in the quality of your renders shows on a side by side like this. I imagine you struggled to find a suitable photo at a good resolution. Your renders should also take up more room in the sig since they are currently half as tall as the bg. Usually, you want the render to run the length of the sig.