Official Arbitration Thread

[KoltClassic]

Submission Date: 6/29/20
Submission Link: https://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?showtopic=23541
Contested Sig(s): I'll contest the penguin sig ( first ).


Grade Changes: 4/7 -> 5/7

$500,000

[Jangorhino]

Submission Date: 6/28/20
Submission Link: https://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?showtopic=...ndpost&p=319343

Contested Sig(s): All of them.

1. I want to know how you’re grading these.
2. You didn’t even grade one of the gfx in this post.
3. I can’t wait to hear this.


Grade Changes: 3rd submission 4/7 -> 6/7

$1,000,000

[Jangorhino]

Submission Date:6/15/20
Submission Link: https://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?showtopic=...ndpost&p=315668
Contested Sig(s): 1 and 2


Let’s flesh this out.

The cutout and swap on the first one gets overlooked because of what? That’s what I want to know. How about that nameplate? Explain how this a 4.

The logo work on the second graphic pushes it past a 3.

Would love to know exactly how you grade these. Can’t wait to dial it in and take you all to the cleaners every week.


Grade Changes: 1st submission 4/7 -> 5/7

$500,000

[Frostbite]

Submission Date: 7/10/20
Submission Link: https://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?showtopic=23656
Contested Sig: the only one (duh)

Graphics that receive this grade are generally memes and hastily done photoshops. Changes to the render, text and/or background are minimal or non-existent.

Idk, I feel like I put more effort in it than just a "meme." Sure the render is a stick figure, but the background + "jersey" + text deserve at least a 2.




Grade change was already made in submission

[Jangorhino]

Submission Date: 7/7/2020
Submission Link:https://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?showtopic=...ndpost&p=322157
Contested Sig(s):

both please.

i honeslty dont know how im not supposed to be offended at this point.


Grade changes: 1st submission 4/7 -> 5/7

$500,000

[Jangorhino]

Submission Date: 7/2/2020
Submission Link: https://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?showtopic=...ndpost&p=320606
Contested Sig(s):

all sigs please

specifically, id like a point by point breakdown on how the first sig is graded a 5. ive seen first hand far inferior sigs get higher grades.


Grade changes: 2nd submission 4/7 -> 5/7, 3rd submission 5/7 -> 6/7, 4th submission 4/7 -> 5/7

$1,500,000

[Amidships]

Submission Date: Jul 13 2020
Submission Link: Montain Sigs
Contested Sig(s): Both. Feedback given for these sigs reads as more in line with a score of 6/7.

Edited with appropriate link on new forums.

Grade changes: 1st submission 5/7 -> 6/7, 2nd submission 5/7 -> 6/7

$1,000,000

[Daybe]

Submission Date: 6/27/2020
Submission Link: https://forums.sim-football.com/showthre...#pid319041
Contested Sig(s): First


I mean, original grader gave it a 7, at the very least I wanna know why it was bumped down/get an opinion from multiple graders

Grade reverted to a 7/7

$500,000

[Rufio_NZ]

Sub date:
Sub link:https://forums.sim-football.com/showthread.php?tid=25059
Contested: Mith 3/7. Just after a 4. Swaps are nice and took a bit of time (albeit I am thinking now the purple might need some correction) and I worked with Mith a bit to get to that end result. Plus. How you gonna mark that a 3/7 with a sneaky Gandalf and Lotr theme word style thing.


Grade changes: 1st submission 3/7 -> 4/7

$500,000

[Jangorhino]

Submission Date: 9/18

Submission Link: sig link

Contested Sig(s): only sig on the thread

not sure if the grader caught it or not, but there are 3 pretty big GIF swaps on this sig. the name placard was changed from AJ Green to Michael Magic in two areas and the parking sign is changed from player parking to executive parking.

Grade changed to a 6/7

$500,000