11-29-2019, 12:56 PM (This post was last modified: 11-29-2019, 02:58 PM by Nokazoa.)
3.5/5 850k. This one is actually fairly hard to grade. The first thing that comes to mind is it reminds me of something I would do, so I may be uniquely qualified to talk about what works and doesn't in this type of sig. I think the biggest thing holding it back is the render. It isn't the highest resolution for a sig, but I think its more the render itself that hurts. The player is currently under some intense light, and its almost too much. Maybe this could be toned down by making some adjustments with the curves. Also, I think your signature gets a tad lost due to how thin the signature is. Perhaps a different color? Maybe duplicate the layer and offset it slightly? Either way, it should allow it to pop some. Lastly is that your sig is too close to your canvas edge so it leads to some cutoff. A minor thing to keep in mind. All in all, its pretty close to being a four for me. I like the direction your sigs are going.