(06-11-2017, 09:13 PM)Kendrick Wrote:I think the reason that thought comes across is because we aren't hear to "learn" were here to submit and have fun with our player. Activity goes up if people know their graphics will actually give them a chunk of cash. You want to encourage submissions, not decrease them. You can give feedback still even if they get auto 5's, like the VHL does.My only real concern with auto 5's, is that you see the quality of work decrease.
I mean there is no perfect system, or not that I can think of. The old VHL format was really close. But fundamental flaud as again, it's dependant on, the quality and settings of the screen ones veiwing it on, the mood of the grader, graders sobriety level, personal opinion, personal likes and dislikes, personal feelings.
We can't just word count GFX and hand out cash. We also can't acuretly rate a users effort level and/or punish those who try hard but will just never be as talented as others. Nor should we disregard the effort put in on any program. @Esa77
But this is fun, very fucking serious fun! Should people really judged at all, beyond there own judgement of there work?
I honestly have no answer and no matter what someone will be unhappy.
:old:
PS I hate grading paint, it's to arbitrary.