I put this in the GFX LR, I don't want anyone trying to guess my thought process so here it is. If you're unsatisfied with your service, I direct you to the link at the bottom. Use it or don't fucking snivel.
Basically I still want to be nice to new artist, usually a 5 or 4 on there first work. From there we want to allow them to find a comfortable ability with PS. So this means still grading on the nice side of things but challenge them to get better. If you don't see progress in their ability, or at least attempt to get better. Their grades need to reflect it by increasingly getting worse.
The idea is to teach and push them to get better.
With the more experienced members, we want to reward them when they have done their best. But we also can't allow them to submit trash in comparison to their skill. I personally grade harder when I see a very good GFX artist submit sub par work. For their ability level that is.
As of right now we have to just continue to use our current grading scale and stay consistent in how we grade. It's obvious people want to see a change in how we grade. But I as of yet i haven't seen anything I feel is fair to everyone.
Here is the discussion I started.
http://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?showtopic=1182&st=0
Basically I still want to be nice to new artist, usually a 5 or 4 on there first work. From there we want to allow them to find a comfortable ability with PS. So this means still grading on the nice side of things but challenge them to get better. If you don't see progress in their ability, or at least attempt to get better. Their grades need to reflect it by increasingly getting worse.
The idea is to teach and push them to get better.
With the more experienced members, we want to reward them when they have done their best. But we also can't allow them to submit trash in comparison to their skill. I personally grade harder when I see a very good GFX artist submit sub par work. For their ability level that is.
As of right now we have to just continue to use our current grading scale and stay consistent in how we grade. It's obvious people want to see a change in how we grade. But I as of yet i haven't seen anything I feel is fair to everyone.
Here is the discussion I started.
http://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?showtopic=1182&st=0