So at 8th in the table I am exactly the right amount of biased, good to know!
It's a delicate balancing act. Being just the right amount of homer. Too little homer and you're not doing enough to offset everyone else's slight homer. Too much homer though and then this happens.
Hank Winchester (S25 - Current) - Scrub
Angus Winchester (S1-S12) - 4x Ultimus Champ - #2 Career Sacks - Hall of Fame
Cooter Bigsby (S14-S23) - S23 Ultimus Champ - #4 Career Yards - #4 Career TDs - 2x MVP - Hall of Fame
Offensive Player Of The Year -- Forrest Gump -- 3.5 -- 1 -- Difference: -2.5 (Biggest Homer Pick)
:sob: [OPTION]===========================================
[OPTION]DSFL Regular Season Stats [OPTION] Tackles: 106 [OPTION] TFLs: 7 [OPTION] FF/FR: 1/1 [OPTION] Sacks: 3 [OPTION] Interceptions: 3 [OPTION] Pass Deflections: 9 [OPTION] Touchdowns: 1
[OPTION]=========================================== [OPTION]DSFL Playoff Stats [OPTION] Tackles: 25 [OPTION] TFLs: 0 [OPTION] FF/FR: 1/0 [OPTION] Sacks: 3 [OPTION] Interceptions: 0 [OPTION] Pass Deflections: 2 [OPTION]===========================================
[OPTION]ISFL Regular Season Stats [OPTION] Tackles: 78 [OPTION] TFLs: 5 [OPTION] FF/FR: 1/2 [OPTION] Sacks: 8 [OPTION] Interceptions: 1 [OPTION] Pass Deflections: 8 [OPTION] Touchdowns: 0 [OPTION] Receptions: 419
[OPTION] Receiving Yards: 3681
[OPTION] Receiving Touchdowns: 25
[OPTION] Kick Return Yards: 5367
[OPTION] Kick Return TDs: 1 [OPTION] Punt Return Yards: 1651 [OPTION] Punt Return TDs: 5 [OPTION] Pancakes: 242 [OPTION]===========================================
[OPTION]ISFL Postseason Stats [OPTION] Rushing Yards: 926 [OPTION] Yards per Carry: 4.56 [OPTION] Rushing Touchdowns: 7 [OPTION] Receptions: 44 [OPTION] Receiving Yards: 408 [OPTION] Receiving Touchdowns: 4 [OPTION] Kick Return Yards: 653 [OPTION] Kick Return TDs: 0 [OPTION] Punt Return Yards: 192 [OPTION] Punt Return TDs: 0 [OPTION] Pancakes: 28 [OPTION]=========================================== [OPTION]Trophy Case/Achievements: [OPTION] S15 DSFL RBotY [OPTION] S15 DSFL MVP [OPTION] S16 Pro Bowler (RB) [OPTION] S17 Pro Bowler (RB) [OPTION] S18 RBotY [OPTION] S18 PERotY [OPTION] S18 OPotY [OPTION] S18 Pro Bowler (RB)
[OPTION] S19 Pro Bowler (RB & Returner)
[OPTION] S20 Pro Bowler (RB & Returner)
[OPTION] S21 Pro Bowler (OFlex & Returner)
[OPTION] S21 Ultimus Champion
[OPTION] S21 Ultimus MVP
[OPTION] S22 Pro Bowler (RB & Returner)
[OPTION] Most Rushing TDs in a DSFL season (S15, 20)
[OPTION] 3rd Most Rushing TDs in a DSFL season (S14, 18) [OPTION] 5th Most Career Rushing Yards
[OPTION] 9th Most Career Rushing TDs
[OPTION] 7th Most Career Scrimmage Yards
[OPTION] 8th Most Career Scrimmage TDs
[OPTION] 5th Most Career Punt Return TDs
[OPTION] 5th Most Career All-Purpose Yards
[OPTION] 8th Most Career All-Purpose TDs
[OPTION] 4th Most Career Postseason Rushing Yards
[OPTION] 2nd Most Career Postseason Rushing TDs
[OPTION] 2nd Most Career Postseason Scrimmage Yards
[OPTION] 2nd Most Career Postseason Scrimmage TDs [OPTION] 10th Most Career Postseason Kick Return Yards
[OPTION] 7th Most Career Postseason Punt Return Yards
[OPTION] 2nd Most Career Postseason All-Purpose Yards
[OPTION] 2nd Most Career Postseason All-Purpose TDs
I know we only had a few nominations but I’m glad to see I pretty much hit the mark for Baltimore
07-30-2020, 10:58 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-30-2020, 11:00 AM by Memento Mori.)
(07-30-2020, 03:34 PM)speculadora Wrote:honestly I feel like hippo and maybe even Philly should be stripped of voting rights next season. and there should be some looking into how far this type of voting dates back. treat awards process like garbage, your ballot should be placed directly in the garbage.For clarity: I think it was dumb that my GMs voted for me because I don’t think I deserved to win any awards. I’m restating a point I made in the awards thread, but (at least according to the way this model calculates bias) every team/HO member was at least somewhat biased except Bex. I think given the current awards process (which I think is pretty bad and I’ve written about it at length in a previous media post), it’d be really harsh to strip a team’s voting rights. There are team reps who believe, and I believe the rep system encourages this, that their job is to get as many of their teammates on the ballot as possible and to further their teammate’s chances of winning an award. Imaginary Award A has 5 nominees, from Teams 1-5. Teams 6-12 do not have a nominee. Everything up until the final round of GM voting, in my opinion, is set up to encourage people to be as biased as possible. Either you expect Teams 1-5 to vote for their player and Teams 6-12 to vote unbiasedly and pick the best candidate - which I’m not sure is a great system but at least it kinda makes sense - or you expect that finally, after a biased process everyone suddenly stops being biased and acts completely objectively when casting the final vote. If our expectation is the former, and we expect people to be biased, then HO shouldn’t have a vote unless HO has 12 members from the 12 teams because otherwise some teams have more biased voters than others. If our expectation is the latter, then the system is ridiculous and contradictory. [OPTION]S24 (PHI): 16 GP, 73 tackles, 1 TFL, 2 FF, 3 sacks, 5 INTs, 10 PDs, 2 TDs
[OPTION]S25 (PHI): 16 GP, 67 tackles, 4 INTs, 13 PDs, 1 TD [OPTION]S26 (OCO): 16 GP, 68 tackles, 1 TFL, 1 sack, 2 INTs, 10 PDs [OPTION]S27 (OCO): 16 GP, 116 tackles, 4 INTs, 23 PDs, 1 TD [OPTION]S28 (OCO): 16 GP, 84 tackles, 1 FF, 1 FR, 3 INTs, 20 PDs, 1 TD [OPTION]S29 (OCO): 16 GP, 99 tackles, 3 FF, 1 FR, 5 INTs, 23 PDs, 1 TD [OPTION]============================================================= [OPTION]ISFL Playoff Stats: [OPTION]S23 (PHI): 1 GP, 2 tackles [OPTION]S26 (OCO): 1 GP, 5 tackles, 2 PDs [OPTION]============================================================= [OPTION]Trophies and Achievements: [OPTION]Drafted 35th Overall by Myrtle Beach in the S21 DSFL Draft [OPTION]S21 Ultimini Champion [OPTION]S21 DSFL Pro Bowl Selection [OPTION]S21 DSFL Defensive Back of the Year Nominee [OPTION]Drafted 4th Overall by Philadelphia in the S22 ISFL Draft [OPTION]S23 ISFL Pro Bowl Selection [OPTION]S23 ISFL Cornerback of the Year Nominee [OPTION]S23 ISFL Defensive Performance of the Year Nominee [OPTION]S24 ISFL Pro Bowl Selection [OPTION]S24 ISFL Cornerback of the Year Nominee [OPTION]S26 ISFL Pro Bowl Selection
[OPTION]S26 ISFL Returner of the Year Nominee [OPTION]S29 ISFL Pro Bowl Selection [OPTION]S29 ISFL Cornerback of the Year Nominee [OPTION]============================================================= Player | Update | Wiki | Twitter (07-30-2020, 11:58 AM)Memento Mori Wrote:For clarity: I think it was dumb that my GMs voted for me because I don’t think I deserved to win any awards. I agree with you on the whole team rep piece of the awards committee - it actively promotes bias. ideally there'd be 5+ people who are fully plugged into what's going on league wide making those decisions, and if there aren't that many of those people then there's another conversation to be had about the awards process top to bottom, and the committee in particular. that being said, the GM's job and the award rep's job are fundamentally different and fundamentally separate. it's not like Laser is being asked to go fight to get OCO guys on the ballot and then turn around and be an impartial judge of their performance. that's the whole reason GM's aren't on the committee. if a GM is incapable of separating the voting process from a process that doesn't even involve them then they shouldn't even be voting in the first place because that'd be ridiculous. the award system might be flawed, but I refuse to accept the argument that GMs can't be expected to be unbiased voters as a separate act from the committee process that they're excluded from entirely. (07-30-2020, 04:27 PM)speculadora Wrote:I agree with you on the whole team rep piece of the awards committee - it actively promotes bias. ideally there'd be 5+ people who are fully plugged into what's going on league wide making those decisions, and if there aren't that many of those people then there's another conversation to be had about the awards process top to bottom, and the committee in particular.Are no GMs allowed on the committee? The committee members aren’t made public but some GMs have implied that they’re on the committee in the past so I assumed that they were. If they’re not allowed then yeah, I’d agree. [OPTION]S24 (PHI): 16 GP, 73 tackles, 1 TFL, 2 FF, 3 sacks, 5 INTs, 10 PDs, 2 TDs
[OPTION]S25 (PHI): 16 GP, 67 tackles, 4 INTs, 13 PDs, 1 TD [OPTION]S26 (OCO): 16 GP, 68 tackles, 1 TFL, 1 sack, 2 INTs, 10 PDs [OPTION]S27 (OCO): 16 GP, 116 tackles, 4 INTs, 23 PDs, 1 TD [OPTION]S28 (OCO): 16 GP, 84 tackles, 1 FF, 1 FR, 3 INTs, 20 PDs, 1 TD [OPTION]S29 (OCO): 16 GP, 99 tackles, 3 FF, 1 FR, 5 INTs, 23 PDs, 1 TD [OPTION]============================================================= [OPTION]ISFL Playoff Stats: [OPTION]S23 (PHI): 1 GP, 2 tackles [OPTION]S26 (OCO): 1 GP, 5 tackles, 2 PDs [OPTION]============================================================= [OPTION]Trophies and Achievements: [OPTION]Drafted 35th Overall by Myrtle Beach in the S21 DSFL Draft [OPTION]S21 Ultimini Champion [OPTION]S21 DSFL Pro Bowl Selection [OPTION]S21 DSFL Defensive Back of the Year Nominee [OPTION]Drafted 4th Overall by Philadelphia in the S22 ISFL Draft [OPTION]S23 ISFL Pro Bowl Selection [OPTION]S23 ISFL Cornerback of the Year Nominee [OPTION]S23 ISFL Defensive Performance of the Year Nominee [OPTION]S24 ISFL Pro Bowl Selection [OPTION]S24 ISFL Cornerback of the Year Nominee [OPTION]S26 ISFL Pro Bowl Selection
[OPTION]S26 ISFL Returner of the Year Nominee [OPTION]S29 ISFL Pro Bowl Selection [OPTION]S29 ISFL Cornerback of the Year Nominee [OPTION]============================================================= Player | Update | Wiki | Twitter |
|