Result of Noble Appeal

[iamslm22]

Cooter Bigsby: Transcendental Talent or Just Another Noble Multi?

A little bit of column A a little of column B

[Jiggly_333]

bringing up things he was already punished for as reasons why he should be punished the one time he might not be guilty is not something that sits well with me

if management wants to say "fuck this we're just done with the whole possibility" thats fine and understandable but this response isnt that

this is....revenge

This is my point. With the fact that other sites are not seeing what you're seeing in the same evidence you were given (I said the wrong thing earlier, but my point was about proof). The SHL didn't even give out a punishment in the first place and they have the most history with Noble and his multi'd past. Any sort of suspicious activity here and that person is instantly a Noble multi.

Since Noble's return, he's been a much better person. And if they were his multis, why would he seek a return with his own account in the first place? That just seems unnecessary when mckee was already established. There's too many holes in connecting this to Noble specifically. I believe there were multis in play, but I firmly believe they were mckee's.

Yes, I've gone to bat for him in the past and that time you also basically railroaded your way through to find what you believe is justice. Putting in mind your own personal search for Noble in everyone, you would have a predisposition to believe that all these people were multis. But in other leagues where they looked at the situation on its own merits, they found him not guilty. The fact that everyone has the same final decision except this league means there has to be some sort of disconnect and I believe that it's based in bias.

[iamslm22]

This is my point. With the fact that other sites are not seeing what you're seeing in the same evidence you were given (I said the wrong thing earlier, but my point was about proof). The SHL didn't even give out a punishment in the first place and they have the most history with Noble and his multi'd past. Any sort of suspicious activity here and that person is instantly a Noble multi.

Since Noble's return, he's been a much better person. And if they were his multis, why would he seek a return with his own account in the first place? That just seems unnecessary when mckee was already established. There's too many holes in connecting this to Noble specifically. I believe there were multis in play, but I firmly believe they were mckee's.

Yes, I've gone to bat for him in the past and that time you also basically railroaded your way through to find what you believe is justice. Putting in mind your own personal search for Noble in everyone, you would have a predisposition to believe that all these people were multis. But in other leagues where they looked at the situation on its own merits, they found him not guilty. The fact that everyone has the same final decision except this league means there has to be some sort of disconnect and I believe that it's based in bias.

Yea you're just making assumptions without fact. Feel free to PM me on discord if you wish to further discuss, but just because NSHL and SHL made mistakes doesn't mean we should too.

[iamslm22]

Also if you think that I'm biased that's whatever - you have to also think PDX and Bzerkap are, as well as Dwyer, Manic, Trautner, Oles, Muford, Bovo and Raven. Since this was unanimous both in HO and appeals

[White Cornerback]

Also if you think that I'm biased that's whatever - you have to also think PDX and Bzerkap are, as well as Dwyer, Manic, Trautner, Oles, Muford, Bovo and Raven. Since this was unanimous both in HO and appeals

This goes against my personal opinion, the 9 of you are all biased

[AdamS]

It really isn't. Given his prior history, given his knowledge of how to multi, given the standard he was let back in (anything suspicious and you're gone), this isn't revenge. It's just logic, and improving the site.

and like i said in different words..i'm on board with this for those reasons

i was more talking about dermot's personal crusade specifically

[ErMurazor]

imagine creating multis in 2019

Yeah. Multis are sooooo 2017.

[Durden]

Why do you forsake me in every single sim league?

[AzhekAhriman]

Wat in Tarnation.......